Skip to main content

May 2, 1918 - Don Martin tells air war story and writes Commodore Bennett about competitors

Don Martin diary entry for Thursday, May 2, 1918: 
Wrote a few mail stories. At 2, with [F. J.] Taylor [United Press] and Lieut. Reynolds, motored to aviation field near Toul and got story of German plane brought down by young [James A.] Meissner of Brooklyn. Got back at 6:30. Wrote good story for Paris. Cabled 250 words to New York. Spent evening at the club. Gregg [St. Louis World], [John T.] Parkerson [Associated Press] and [Bert] Ford [International News Service] leaving for the French front. Most of the other correspondents are back here.
Wrote to Mr. Bennett.
My 320 franc watch has refused to run.
Quiet in the North. Germans apparently preparing for another assault.
First good day in weeks.

        The Meissner air war story, dated May 2, was published in the New York Herald on May 3.
                  Brooklyn Man Downs Air Foe In Lofty Fight
Lieutenant James A. Meissner in Battle 
as Pershing Forces Look On
CRASHES WITH ENEMY AS HE POURS IN FIRE
German Machine Falls in Flames 
and Is Fourth Bagged by Americans at Toul 
By DON MARTIN
Special Correspondent of the Herald With the American Army in France 
[Special Cable to the Herald]
WITH THE AMERICAN ARMY IN FRANCE, Thursday
             The brilliant maneuvering of a Brooklyn Flatbush youth, Lieutenant James A. Meissner, brought his victory over a German swift Albatross aeroplane over the Hun line edge of the American sector. Meissner is a graduate of Cornell, 1918 class. He is the most modest of all the fliers and also most skillful. He was complimented on his cleverness by such veterans as [Raoul] Lufbery.
             French and American soldiers who saw the daring attack and his wonderful escape from a situation which would have tried the mettle and skill of the oldest aviator cheered him and later gave him a warm reception.
        The Meissner boy caught the Hum at a trick the Boche had been using to play on the sportsmanship of Americans and the French. When pursued they explode a smoke bomb which is entirely new, then flutter down, expecting the foe to start home, when they make a quick attack on the sympathetic aviator.
         Meissner was ready for this. The Boche fired a smoke bomb and fluttered down a thousand feet, giving the impression that his machine was wrecked and crashing earthward, but the young Cornell man swooped after, firing 200 shots as he went. The Hun righted in a slant and attacked. The airplanes were so close that their wings crashed together. Meissner never stopped during the firing, but kept at it till he saw the Boche machine break in flames and genuinely start earthward.
          The plunge was complete and the wreck fell just inside the German line. By skillful work Meissner guided his machine, with one wing almost gone, to his own lines. I saw him half an hour later and found the blushing boy proud of his achievement.
            “I did the best I could,” he said. “The Hun was tricky, that’s all.” The American got it on him. There are plenty of boys in Flatbush who could lick him on the ground with fists or bayonets.
             A veteran flier, listening, said:-- “You’re a great kid,” then, turning to the others, the veteran said as the flatbush kid blushed:-- “He’s a great kid, boys; call him ‘the rat,’ because he’s a sticker; twenty-one and afraid of nothing that ever walked or flew.”
        Don Martin’s letter of May 2 to Commodore James Gordon Bennett includes complaints about the censorship and insights on the competition between the American war correspondents to “beat’ the others.
Dear Sir:
            ... I have remained here with the main army, believing that to be the best thing for the Herald. I have had several beats for the European edition, notably the engagement at Seicheprey, the bringing down of German planes by Americans and the decoration of the 104th Regiment. I cabled something on each to New York. It does not seem practicable to send the same dispatches to New York and Paris. The censors permit considerable leeway in cables to America but won’t let anything go to Paris which might seem like boasting or glorification of American troops. The theory is that modesty must characterize everything printed in Paris so as not to offend the French and that we must also be careful not to reveal any information to the enemy which gets in a day or two everything printed in Paris. This censorship rule will explain why I am not able to put more punch in the stories in the European edition. I have fought out the censorship matter with the authorities here and in headquarters, insisting that the Herald, in its European edition, must be permitted to have exactly the same privileges the Stars and Stripes has. The Stars and Stripes is an official government newspaper, printed weekly on the Mail presses in Paris and cannot be called a competitor of the Herald. I complained on several occasions that this official paper was allowed to print stories which the Herald could not publish and that it was distinctly unfair. The matter was taken up carefully and from now on the Herald will have precisely the same privileges given to the Stars and Stripes.
            ... Every American officer in France practically gets the [Paris] Herald. I see it in the front line, in the clubs, in the dugouts, everywhere. ... In Neufchateau at seven every evening there is a crowd about the one newsstand waiting for the Herald. All the officers and a great many of the privates buy it. With the number of Americans in France constantly and rapidly increasing the Herald circulation should gain steadily.
            ... On Sunday I took the liberty of sending about 70 words to New York at full rate (25 cents a word)[equivalent to about $4.40 today] to provide a newsy lead to the story about the decoration of the 104th Regiment, Massachusetts. The A. P. man was late getting in and I saw a possibility of getting a beat in New York and in any event a different and newsy introduction. ...
            All the correspondents who went to the other front, to the North, have returned here. The censorship was so rigid the three weeks put in there were lost. I shall remain here unless, in my opinion, it is better for the Herald for me to go to the other front for a brief stay. ... When the big battle in Picardy settles down I should like to make a try for a complete story on, and good interview with, General [Ferdinand] Foch. He is probably a hard man to reach but if it could be done, in my opinion, it would be one of the big stories of the war.
Respectfully,
                      Don Martin

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

‘New war with Israel at any moment’, ‘still digging through rubble’

The news about Iran has taken an ominous tone in the last couple days. Here is some reporting and commentary.  Newsweek on August 18, 2025, reported that Yahya Rahim Safavi, senior military adviser to Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, said ‘ We are not in a ceasefire; we are in a stage of war. No protocol, regulation, or agreement has been written between us and the U.S. or Israel. A new war with Israel could break out at any moment .’  Yonah Jeremy Bob commented in The Jerusalem Post on August 19, 2025, that ‘ Khamenei can either “drink from the poisoned chalice” of diplomatic concessions … or face more airstrikes, possibly next time some targeting him directly ’.   Bob also noted that ‘ right now Iran is still digging through rubbl e’. The U.S. attacked Fordow, Natanz and Esfahan on June 22. Two months of digging. No surprise that there has been no public news about that.

U.S. Sanctions, Middle East views

Trump’s special envoy Witkoff has hit the capitals again; in Tel Aviv Netanyahu probably told him to tell Trump that he will take over all of Gaza; in Moscow Putin probably told him to tell Trump that Ukraine will be destroyed and forget the sanctions. Witkoff didn’t get to number 3 on his list, Iran. But Trump played another ‘ getting to a deal ’ with Iran card, adding sanctions he can later get credit for removing. And the Middle East commentators are worriedly reacting to the Iran situation. Here are some highlights.  From Newsweek:       The U.S. announced on July 30 the largest Iran-related sanctions since 2018 , targeting entities and vessels linked to the country's petroleum sector: 20 oil firms, 5 vessel management companies, 1 wholesaler, and over 115 individuals in 17 countries and regions, including the U.K., Italy, Switzerland, India, the UAE and Hong Kong.       U.S. State Department spokesperson Tammy Bruce said: "Today's Depar...

“Quit the nuclear deal”

The E3 (Britan, France, Germany) upped their ante with a letter to the UN Security Council on August 12, 2025, that included: ‘ if Iran is not willing to reach a diplomatic solution before the end of August 2025, or does not seize the opportunity of an extension, E3 are prepared to trigger the snapback mechanism ’. (AP, Aug 13, 2025)  So far, we have an Iranian response from Parliament member Manouchehr Mottaki — who was Iran’s top diplomat for five years in the 2000s — saying the Iranian parliament has a “ finger on the trigger ” for quitting the Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty. “ We only need 24 hours to approve quitting the nuclear deal, ” if the E3 raises the issue at the U.N. Security Council, Mottaki said. (AP, Aug 13, 2025)  On ‘extension’, following July’s meeting in Istanbul [between E3 and Iran], an E3 diplomat said Iran could delay [snapback] by doing two things [1] renewing cooperation with the Vienna-based IAEA and [2] addressing concerns about its highly enriche...