Skip to main content

June 28, 1918: Don Martin reports German view of Belleau and Torcy battles

Don Martin diary entry for Friday, June 28, 1918
Went with [Edwin] James [New York Times] to the 2nd division. Stopped in Bazu. No shells falling. My finger is better and my throat is better also. Had a pleasant chat with Cameron Mackenzie of the London Chronicle, formerly editor of McClures. Wrote a long mail story on German prisoners. I mailed it, with sketches by a dough boy. I also send by mail a short story of the soldier’s funeral and a clipping on the Pat Donohue story.
        In a dispatch dated Friday, June 28, Don Martin recounts what the German newspapers are reporting about the battles at Belleau Wood and Torcy. It was published in New York Herald on June 29.
AMERICANS HOLD 8 POSITIONS 
ON WESTERN FRONT
General Pershing’s Forces Also Brigaded 
with French at Vital Points
ALLIES ARE READY FOR GERMAN DRIVE
Premier Clemenceau Praises Our Men 
for Brilliant Work at Belleau Wood
By Don Martin
Special Correspondent of the Herald with the American Armies in France
 [Special Cable to the Herald]
WITH THE AMERICAN ARMIES IN FRANCE, Friday [June 28]
           While the armies in France, numbering millions of men, are preparing for the most titanic battle of the Great War, I am permitted to say that the American forces under General Pershing now are occupying eight important positions in the allied line.
            American steel, backed by American valor that has known no defeat, now stretches along the front, facing the enemy from Alsace to Montdidier.
            Americans are on three fronts in Alsace today. Also they face the Boche at Montdidier and northwest of Château-Thierry, at Toul and in Lorraine.
            They are linked with the French at some of the most vital points along the line and they rapidly are preparing to take their places at other important positions at the front.
       They are, as Secretary [Newton] Baker and [Chief of Staff] General [Peyton C.] March predicted, fairly swarming into France, surpassing the most optimistic prophecy.
Praise from French Premier
            Premier Clémenceau, in behalf of the French nation, has paid another tribute to them. He referred to them as the heroes of Belleau Wood. He thanked General Pershing and other officers of the American Expeditionary Forces personally, and asked them to transmit to our men at the front his warmest greetings and congratulations.
        In the face of this – and the things the American “doughboys” have been doing – German newspapers continue to try to minimize the importance of the part they are doing here. They belittled the Americans at Belleau Wood and declared that the insufficiency of their training showed itself in their conduct in the field. The military critic of the Berliner Tageblatt boastfully said that a German regiment almost destroyed an American division, few of the Americans escaping death. He added that the American artillery fire was inconsequential.
          “The work of the Americans is shown in mobile warfare,” General von Biebert was quoted as having said. “The insufficiency of their tactical preparation soon was proved.”
          Speaking of the fighting at Belleau Wood, the Deutsche Tagezeitung said that the Americans were permitted to advance until they became good targets, and then the artillery mowed them down, leaving the ground filled high with dead. It declared that the newspapers which gave the Americans credit for the victory at Belleau Wood did so to “strengthen the spirit of restless France.” The American troops are incapable of independent action, but always must have French commanders, it added.
German View Amuses Americans
          These German newspaper comments were for German consumption and are contained in the latest issues of the Berlin newspapers to reach here. They have caused great amusement in the allied camps and throughout all France, especially in the face of Premier Clémenceau’s statement that the Americans at Belleau Wood showed plenty of initiative and acted under their own direction in planning and executing the entire attack.
             When Premier Clémenceau inspected the Americans he made a deep impression on them. He speaks excellent English, and many of the officers with whom he spoke were not a little embarrassed by his praise of them and their men. He showed them that he was familiar with the record of the brave soldiers, whom he referred to as the heroes of Bouresches and Belleau. He declared that all France is proud of them and wants them to know that they have justified their reputation and showed the same stuff that characterized the men in blue whom he saw at Richmond in civil war times when he witnessed Grant’s entrance into that city.
Cleaned Up at Torcy
            The attempt of the German newspapers to hold up the American troops to ridicule is in striking contrast to the statements made by German prisoners who saw our men in action. They unqualifiedly declared that the American soldiers are causing worry and dismay to the German commanders.
             Especially are these German press attacks ridiculous when they are viewed in the light of what actually happened at Belleau Wood, where in the last fight our forces virtually wiped out the enemy.
        Not only does the German government and press attempt to make their people believe that the Americans failed at Belleau Wood but also at Torcy, where the completeness of our victory was not revealed until to-day.
         One of the most famous units of our forces here cleaned the Hun out of Torcy last Tuesday [June 25]. The American artillery paved the way for the attack and for thirteen hours sent a hail of steel into the German positions. Then with a dash our men went at them.
            When patrols examined the wood there and saw the places where the Germans were entrenched they found hundreds of enemy dead but not a sign of life. Now we are in complete control of this wood.
Hospital is Hun Target
           I saw hundreds of German prisoners marching into our prison camps back of the American lines. I asked a German officer who was one of the prisoners what he thought of it all.
           “We know that you have a lot of men here,” he told me, “but we will attend to them when the time comes.”
          German batteries to-day shelled a French village where an American Red Cross hospital is located. Apparently the enemy is determined to hit this place. The hospital occupies an old church and contains a few wounded Americans and a few wounded Germans. It has been an important dressing station, and the Germans must know of it, for the aviators flew over the village frequently in the last few days.
             I was in this hospital when one of the shells broke. Other projectiles fell at the end of the short street in which is the hospital. The wounded men were hurriedly removed from the hospital and carried into the fields near by. The surgeons were preparing to move out of the place when many shells fell in nearby places but missed the hospital.
          Like the average German shelling, there was much noise but little damage. The entire affair, however, was sufficient to show the anger of the Germans and also that they are determined to wage against the Americans their old-time barbarous warfare.
             Since last Tuesday night’s assault the German forces near Belleau Wood and near all American sectors have been quiet.
          To-day it is hardly possible to go anywhere in France without seeing American troops in training in the art of scientific warfare. None of our troops are sent to the front until they are trained perfectly. Our men learn quickly and are fast preparing to do their full share in the rush of the Germans, which, it is expected, will be resumed soon.

         When clashes between our men and the enemy have occurred, the Germans have proved inferior. Now it is all open fighting, which is the strong point of the Americans. It gives a chance for dash and boldness, and in this they excel. Their way of fighting is a revelation to the Germans.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

‘New war with Israel at any moment’, ‘still digging through rubble’

The news about Iran has taken an ominous tone in the last couple days. Here is some reporting and commentary.  Newsweek on August 18, 2025, reported that Yahya Rahim Safavi, senior military adviser to Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, said ‘ We are not in a ceasefire; we are in a stage of war. No protocol, regulation, or agreement has been written between us and the U.S. or Israel. A new war with Israel could break out at any moment .’  Yonah Jeremy Bob commented in The Jerusalem Post on August 19, 2025, that ‘ Khamenei can either “drink from the poisoned chalice” of diplomatic concessions … or face more airstrikes, possibly next time some targeting him directly ’.   Bob also noted that ‘ right now Iran is still digging through rubbl e’. The U.S. attacked Fordow, Natanz and Esfahan on June 22. Two months of digging. No surprise that there has been no public news about that.

U.S. Sanctions, Middle East views

Trump’s special envoy Witkoff has hit the capitals again; in Tel Aviv Netanyahu probably told him to tell Trump that he will take over all of Gaza; in Moscow Putin probably told him to tell Trump that Ukraine will be destroyed and forget the sanctions. Witkoff didn’t get to number 3 on his list, Iran. But Trump played another ‘ getting to a deal ’ with Iran card, adding sanctions he can later get credit for removing. And the Middle East commentators are worriedly reacting to the Iran situation. Here are some highlights.  From Newsweek:       The U.S. announced on July 30 the largest Iran-related sanctions since 2018 , targeting entities and vessels linked to the country's petroleum sector: 20 oil firms, 5 vessel management companies, 1 wholesaler, and over 115 individuals in 17 countries and regions, including the U.K., Italy, Switzerland, India, the UAE and Hong Kong.       U.S. State Department spokesperson Tammy Bruce said: "Today's Depar...

“Quit the nuclear deal”

The E3 (Britan, France, Germany) upped their ante with a letter to the UN Security Council on August 12, 2025, that included: ‘ if Iran is not willing to reach a diplomatic solution before the end of August 2025, or does not seize the opportunity of an extension, E3 are prepared to trigger the snapback mechanism ’. (AP, Aug 13, 2025)  So far, we have an Iranian response from Parliament member Manouchehr Mottaki — who was Iran’s top diplomat for five years in the 2000s — saying the Iranian parliament has a “ finger on the trigger ” for quitting the Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty. “ We only need 24 hours to approve quitting the nuclear deal, ” if the E3 raises the issue at the U.N. Security Council, Mottaki said. (AP, Aug 13, 2025)  On ‘extension’, following July’s meeting in Istanbul [between E3 and Iran], an E3 diplomat said Iran could delay [snapback] by doing two things [1] renewing cooperation with the Vienna-based IAEA and [2] addressing concerns about its highly enriche...