Skip to main content

July 11, 1918: Don Martin sends a flurry of dispatches

Don Martin diary entry for Thursday, July 11, 1918
Roamed around all day with [Edwin] James [New York Times] looking for a copy of a German propaganda newspaper which says Hearst reflects real American opinion of the war. Had luncheon with Lieutenant Feland of the Marines. Wrote 200 word cable on the Hearst propaganda story. Everyone mystified at the delay in the renewed German offensive.
            A short version of Don Martin’s report (Paris Herald July 11) on General Pershing decorating marines with Distinguished Service Crosses was published in the New York Herald on Friday, July 12, without the list of names.
HONOR AMERICANS FOR
DISTINGUISHED SERVICES IN WAR
Marines and Heroes of Belleau Wood Receive Crosses for Brave Deeds
By Don Martin
Special Correspondent of the Herald with the American Armies in France
 [Special Cable to the Herald]
WITH THE AMERICAN ARMIES IN FRANCE, Thursday [July 11]
                On a beautiful spot on the banks of the Marne River Distinguished Service Crosses have been bestowed on 121 Americans, many of whom were marines and heroes of Bouresches and Belleau Wood.
               Of the men who were decorated there were only thirty-three present at the brilliant ceremony. Fifteen, to whom the Distinguished Service Crosses were awarded, are dead, having fallen on the field of battle. The rest are in hospitals.
              An American general, who was present, addressing the men, said that they had written a glorious page in the history of their country. At the same time he admonished them never to forget for what objects the United States entered the war.
            Don Martin’s report of the first use of gas shells by the Americans was published in the Paris Herald on July 12.
AMERICANS DELUGE THE
GERMAN LINES WITH GAS SHELLS
Enemy Attempts Counter Artillery Attack
and Then Is Silent for Twenty-four Hours.
(SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE HERALD.)
By DON MARTIN.
WITH THE AMERICAN ARMIES, Thursday.[July 11]
             Germans attempted a raid early this morning on the Americans north-west of Château-Thierry. Forty Germans crossed No Man's Land, but were unable to penetrate our lines. Two of them were killed. The rest dashed hack to their own line.
             On Monday night the Americans to the east of this point gave the German his first real dose of gas. A deluge of gas shells was sent over during a period of two hours, and from reports reaching our lines the Germans suffered heavily. For a short time after the deluge of shells started the Germans attempted a counter-artillery attack, but their guns became silent very soon and were not heard from for more than twenty-four hours.
             The Germans have been lavish in their use of gas along the American sectors. On the theory that the best way to treat the Hun is to give him the same as he sends, the Americans decided to drench his front lines and back areas with gas, and there is reason to believe that this theory is a good one.
             The German soldiers, it is known, are now carrying a small package of a chemical which they use as an antidote for gas.
             On July 11 Don Martin updated his report of the day before about Quentin Roosevelt, published in the Paris Herald on July 12.  
Quentin Roosevelt Mistook German For Amex Planes
(Special Telegram to the Paris Herald)
By Don Martin 
With The American Army, Thursday.
               It is now known that Lieutenant Quentin Roosevelt had a narrow escape from death on Tuesday when he is believed to have brought down a Boche plane.
               He was flying with an American squadron when he lost his way. After a short time he saw what he supposed were the Americans from whom he had strayed, and veered his course to join them. He flew for some time in ignorance of the fact that his supposed colleagues were Germans.
              As soon as he made the discovery he began pumping away at one of them with his machine-gun. The others turned to aid their companion, but Lieutenant Roosevelt, seeing the odds against him turned his course homeward and escaped, although bullets passed perilously near his plane.
           Don Martin was able to report on another unmailed letter, this one recovered from a dead German. It was published in the Paris Herald on July 12.
German Soldier Tells Brother 
“End” Is Still Far Off
(SPECIAL TELEGRAM TO THE HERALD.)
By DON MARTIN.
WITH THE AMERICAN ARMIES, Thursday. [July 11]
               Apparently there are some German soldiers who are not certain the war will end this year. The following letter which was taken from a dead German, having been written to him by his brother, also a member of the German army, sheds new light on the attitude of some Germans:
      "May 6, 1918.
    "Dear Fritz, I have received your letter of April 24 and thank you very much, and I am glad to hear that you are again in a good sector and hope that you will stay there long, because the end is still far off.
        "I also have moved further back on April 25. The quietest place that I have been on the Western front is a small village by the name of Chambley. It is only two hours' railroad ride from Metz. Here a food distribution centre is being constructed. We are building a field railway and it is very hard work, but what does one not do if one must do it. How long it will take, no one knows. It is rumored that our division will be transferred but one cannot believe it, because nobody knows it in advance.
        "If I cannot get away I would like to stay here very long, even if it is not very easy work. I hope the parcel sending restriction will soon be removed, because I have not had any butter for a long time and we are not fed very well here by the food depot, because nothing has yet arrived. Therefore, the subsistence as a whole is not very good.
        "Franz is in a recruit depot, but I do not know where he is. I believe in Belgium, where he obtains good food. He has been schooled in the use of the machine-gun. They are used to protect the artillery. He has already volunteered, but he is still there, and I have written to him that he should stay there as long as possible because here it is different than in Russia. He will too soon repent and much prefer to do heavy fatigue and eat less, but maybe he thinks otherwise.
        “I had no letter from home since the 23rd, but yesterday one came. The grain has been scratched together. Lena writes that the grain looks poor, and that we can believe. However, I am glad, for a mediocre crop gives something, and that is better than nothing. Now they can also have potatoes. There has been another revision of cattle. Before Christmas my parents had to give up three heads; now again they must release two, but when one observes how much meat a division receives one need not wonder at this confiscation. Also the amount of hay and straw that a division uses is surprising and one marvels from where it all comes.

        "We are thinking this year of an end and now in the newspapers we read that England and France are preparing for a winter campaign."
        Don Martin  mailed to New York a dispatch, dated July 11, about his interviews with German prisoners. It was published in the Sunday edition of the New York Herald on July 28.
DON MARTIN FINDS GERMAN PRISONERS A DOWNCAST LOT, CONCEDING AMERICANS 
MAY BE THE DECISIVE FACTOR
By DON MARTIN
Special Correspondent of the Herald with the American Armies in France
[Special to the Herald]
WITH THE AMERICAN ARMIES IN FRANCE, July 11
        More than three hundred German prisoners, among them six officers—a captain and five lieutenants—all Prussians, were standing or lounging in an orchard behind an American headquarters one morning recently when I called there. They had been captured the night before by a regiment of Americans who even without this achievement to their credit already had earned a reputation for valor and dash which has stirred all France.
        These men were brought in from the Bois de Belleau and a stretch of woodland adjoining it. They were a motley looking crowd. There was here and there one with a look of kindness and intelligence in his eye, but by far the greater number looked like the very lowest order of human beings. After watching them and talking with them it was easy to understand how the Germans can commit the outrages which have marked their conduct since the beginning of the war. They are totally unlike the French, who are always neat in appearance and suave in manner, no matter whether they come from the congested cities or from the outlying regions. The Germans are no more like the Americans than a Hottentot is like an Albino. In captivity the majority of t hem are shrinking, cringing persons who express a readiness to tell all they know, but who, it is often learned, practice deceit whenever possible.
Prussians are Proud
        The prisoners taken in the haul at Belleau probably are not representative of the great mass of German soldiers, but among them were, nevertheless, many privates and non-commissioned officers who are ranked among the best fighters Germany has. Of the three hundred prisoners I should say 125 were Prussians, and all were proud of it. They were insolent and swaggering even when treated with kindness. There were forty Alsatians, and they were obviously of a different type. All of them thanked the Americans for food given to them and said they were glad to be taken prisoner because they had been drafted from their homes to fight for a cause for which they have no sympathy.
        More than a score of the Germans spoke English in a small way. I talked to all of them to get their point of view and found them, almost to a man, socialistic in their tendencies but devoted worshippers of the Kaiser and the German government. Here is what one man, about forty years old, who had been in Dublin and London, said:--
        “We don’t want war, but we must fight, because if we don’t we shall lose all our country. We don’t want Belgium. We don’t want anything but just Germany, but the English and French expect to take that away from us, and so we are fighting.”
        “No one wants to take your country away from you” I said to him, “That is the argument used by your Kaiser to keep you fighting. Why don’t you all quit fighting if you don’t want war?”
“We Can’t Stop”
        “We have fought too long now and lost too many men. We can’t stop. It will all be over, though, in three months—maybe in August.”
        “Has Germany particular hatred for American soldiers?”
        “German soldiers like all soldiers. We like American soldiers.”
       “Do  you know why America came into the war?”
       “To save England. It’s all money. France started to help Russia because Russia owes her so much money. Then England helped France because France owes her money, and then the United States came in because England owes her a lot and it would be all lost if England lost the war.”
        That about epitomizes the mental attitude of the average illiterate German soldier toward the war. He has been fed on German propaganda, and the government has made every effort imaginable to keep him from getting information from outside.
        I talked with a rough looing lieutenant toward whom several privates shot looks of hatred. “He’s a bad man,” said one afterward.
        “Are you a Prussian,” I asked him.
        “I am,” he said sternly in German.
        “Do you expect Germany is going to win the war?”
        “Of course she is, and she is going to win it this summer—maybe iin a few weeks.”
        “Do you know how many soldiers the United States has here now?’”
        “I understand there are 700,000.”
        “Suppose American had a million men in the line, wouldn’t that insure the defeat of Germany?”
“A Million Men is Nothing”
        He half scowled and half smiled.
        “A million men is nothing. Americans can fight pretty good, but they have a great surprise coming to them soon. They’ll find out. Hindenburg is going to win this summer probably, but if he doesn’t he will win next year, and if not then the next year, and in ten years if he has to fight that long.”
        “Will the people of Germany stand the war so long as that?”
        “The German people want to win the war, and they know they will, America or no America.”
         “Don’t the people in Germany realize that they must be wrong when practically al the civilized world is against them?”
         He stuck his nose up in a highly impertinent way, partly at my audacity and partly at the suggestion that the civilized world is against Germany.
        Two officers were being questioned by American intelligence officers when one of the Americans, in a perfectly polite way, said:--
        “You know, don’t you, that the Americans are fighting a political war—that they are fighting the German government, not the German people?”
        The three officers jumped to their feet like automatons and in unison said:--
        “Da is eins” (“They are one”).
        A young man who was for a time a waiter in a London hotel and who speaks fluent English said he was drafted to fight and is glad to be out of it. 
        “I’m going to the United States when the war is over,” he said. “I was intending to go there when the war started and I had to go to Germany.”
        “Do the Germans think the Americans make pretty good fighters?” I asked.
        He smiled.
        “We know they do,” he replied.
        “Do most of the Germans think they can win the war?”
        “They did until the big offensive was stopped and they heard that Americans were landing in France at the rate of ten thousand a day. Now they don’t know what to think. Their officers, who are nearly all Prussians, tell them they must keep on fighting or be killed, and so we keep on fighting. They are getting tired and discouraged, but they won’t tell you so because they think their officers will hear of it and kill them when they go back after the war. They are ignorant, most of them.”
        “Have the Germans lost many men since they began running up against the Americans?”
        “Yes, your artillery fire has raised the devil with them. It never gives them any rest, and then when it is quiet the Americans keep shooting at them with machine guns.”
Fear Death After Capture
        “Do the ignorant soldiers believe the Americans will kill them after they are taken prisoners?”
        “Some of them believe it. They are told this by their officers so they will not surrender.”
        One of the officers was in a hospital treated for a wound in the neck. He glanced at a newspaper—a European edition of the Herald—which a wounded American was reading nearby. A big headline told of the collapse of the Austrian offensive. The German officer leaned over in his eagerness to see what the words said, and he apparently was able to get a fair understanding.
        “What do you think of the defeat of the Austrians by the Italians?” I asked him.
        He  asked for a translation of the leading words in the heading. Then he said:--
        “That’s only lies printed to keep up the courage of the Italian, French and English people.”
        It was astonishing to learn how little the Germans know of the actual developments of the war and how wedded they are to the belief that everything their own government tells them is true and everything stated by the Allies is false. Many of the prisoners believed that New York city had been partly destroyed by fire from German warships; that Philadelphia was in ruins; that nearly all the American transports had been sunk with all on board; that submarines had the American seaboard under a hard blockade and that England is a country of desolation and starvation. When I assured the simple minded Germans that their information was not only somewhat exaggerated but wholly wrong they shook their heads and inwardly branded me as an allied propagandist determined to hide the real truth from the poor “downtrodden German.”
        I watched more than twenty German wounded treated in this quaint little hospital, the staff of which is made up of eminent surgeons. The Germans were treated in turn with the Americans and received just the same care precisely. They wee amazed at this. Some of them smoked cigarettes which the American attendants gave them. A few asked for food, saying they had not eaten in two and a half days because of the heavy artillery fire of the Americans, which prevented the bringing up of supplies. Bread and coffee were furnished and the soldiers ate ravenously.
        It is a tribute to the honest dealing of the Americans that the orders given to every soldier is that not a single thing must be taken from a prisoner. All of his personal belongings are taken from him, but all are returned except notebooks, letters and such data as may contain information of use to the captors. When the three hundred prisoners of whom I write were marched to the orchard where they were to rest until the records of all were taken, an American officer in my presence said in the most fearsome tones:- “Any man who takes a single thing from one of these men will be court-martialed.”

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

‘New war with Israel at any moment’, ‘still digging through rubble’

The news about Iran has taken an ominous tone in the last couple days. Here is some reporting and commentary.  Newsweek on August 18, 2025, reported that Yahya Rahim Safavi, senior military adviser to Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, said ‘ We are not in a ceasefire; we are in a stage of war. No protocol, regulation, or agreement has been written between us and the U.S. or Israel. A new war with Israel could break out at any moment .’  Yonah Jeremy Bob commented in The Jerusalem Post on August 19, 2025, that ‘ Khamenei can either “drink from the poisoned chalice” of diplomatic concessions … or face more airstrikes, possibly next time some targeting him directly ’.   Bob also noted that ‘ right now Iran is still digging through rubbl e’. The U.S. attacked Fordow, Natanz and Esfahan on June 22. Two months of digging. No surprise that there has been no public news about that.

U.S. Sanctions, Middle East views

Trump’s special envoy Witkoff has hit the capitals again; in Tel Aviv Netanyahu probably told him to tell Trump that he will take over all of Gaza; in Moscow Putin probably told him to tell Trump that Ukraine will be destroyed and forget the sanctions. Witkoff didn’t get to number 3 on his list, Iran. But Trump played another ‘ getting to a deal ’ with Iran card, adding sanctions he can later get credit for removing. And the Middle East commentators are worriedly reacting to the Iran situation. Here are some highlights.  From Newsweek:       The U.S. announced on July 30 the largest Iran-related sanctions since 2018 , targeting entities and vessels linked to the country's petroleum sector: 20 oil firms, 5 vessel management companies, 1 wholesaler, and over 115 individuals in 17 countries and regions, including the U.K., Italy, Switzerland, India, the UAE and Hong Kong.       U.S. State Department spokesperson Tammy Bruce said: "Today's Depar...

“Quit the nuclear deal”

The E3 (Britan, France, Germany) upped their ante with a letter to the UN Security Council on August 12, 2025, that included: ‘ if Iran is not willing to reach a diplomatic solution before the end of August 2025, or does not seize the opportunity of an extension, E3 are prepared to trigger the snapback mechanism ’. (AP, Aug 13, 2025)  So far, we have an Iranian response from Parliament member Manouchehr Mottaki — who was Iran’s top diplomat for five years in the 2000s — saying the Iranian parliament has a “ finger on the trigger ” for quitting the Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty. “ We only need 24 hours to approve quitting the nuclear deal, ” if the E3 raises the issue at the U.N. Security Council, Mottaki said. (AP, Aug 13, 2025)  On ‘extension’, following July’s meeting in Istanbul [between E3 and Iran], an E3 diplomat said Iran could delay [snapback] by doing two things [1] renewing cooperation with the Vienna-based IAEA and [2] addressing concerns about its highly enriche...